Your browser isn't supported
It looks like you're using an old web browser. To get the most out of the site and to ensure guides display correctly, we suggest upgrading your browser now. Download the latest:

The MoneySaving Forum: join to chat & swap tips with other MoneySavers. Learn how in the Forum Introduction Guide

Is the cash ISA dead?

Can it beat 5% bank accounts and the new personal allowance?

Get Our Free Weekly Email!

For all the latest deals, guides and loopholes - join the 10m who get it. Don't miss out

Martin | Edited by Helen S

Updated January 2017

Lily on a book

In years gone by, at the beginning of April, every saver would've been dashing to stuff money in their tax-free Individual Saving Account (ISA).

Yet for many, the saver's darling has lost its lustre – pitiful interest rates, the new 'you can earn £1,000 tax-free' savings allowance and 5% interest paying bank accounts mean many think the cash ISA is dead.

Yet I beg to differ, it isn't dead, it's just resting – ready to rise phoenix-like in years to come. So to explain why cash in an ISA can still be nicer – let's take it one step at a time.

What is an ISA?

Many needlessly overcomplicate it, but a cash ISA is really just a savings account where you don't pay tax on the interest. Anything you can do with normal savings, such as take your money out the next day, you can do with cash ISAs too.

Every person in the UK aged over 16 can put £15,240 into a cash ISA each tax year. This tax year started on 6 April 2016, so if you haven't used it since then, you've a fresh allowance to use. Crucially, once money is in there, it stays tax-free year after year.

It used to be that you earned £100 interest in a savings account, and after 20% basic-rate tax, you only receive £80 – after higher rate, £60. Yet a cash ISA's tax-free status means you kept the whole £100, which meant ISAs generally won.

Since April 2016, this logic needs a rethink. The new personal savings allowance means 95% of us won't pay any tax at all on savings interest. So, the question is – is there really any point in saving in an ISA?

What's the new personal savings allowance?

Pound signFrom April 2016, for basic-rate taxpayers, the first £1,000 of interest earned in banks, building societies, credit unions and on peer-to-peer loans will not be taxed (it's £500 for a 40% higher-rate taxpayer, 45% additional-rate taxpayers don't get it at all).

That's a £200 maximum annual tax reduction for everyone who qualifies. Read all about how this works in the full Personal Savings Allowance guide.

The top-paying easy-access savings account for a decent chunk of savings pays 1.02%, so in that you could save just over £98,000 as a basic-rate taxpayer, £49,000 higher rate, before breaching the limit.

You can boost the rate by fixing your savings – you can get 1.7% on a three-year fixed savings account, meaning you’d hit the limits with £59,000 as a basic-rate taxpayer and £29,500 as  a higher-rate taxpayer.

If we now all get a personal savings allowance, why bother with an ISA?

Even now the personal savings allowance is here, I've still six reasons why I'd open a cash ISA, rather than just relying on your personal savings allowance.

  • Cash ISAs are tax-free long term

    Filling your cash ISA means you can future-proof your savings against future tax. Even though rates are crap now, when they bounce back, as you'll earn more interest, it could be very valuable especially for those who accrue larger amounts of savings.
    Someone who'd filled their ISA allowance every year since they started in 1999 could now have more than £100,000 including interest protected from the taxman.

  • The savings allowance won't look so generous if interest rates bounce back

    While the allowance looks huge now, if savings rates increase to pre-credit-crunch levels, say 7%, then the £1,000 tax-free interest allowance would be earned on just £14,000 of savings for a basic-rate taxpayer and £7,000 for a higher-rate taxpayer – less than one year's ISA cash.

  • Cash ISA rates often beat normal savings rates

    Over the last few years, the top-paying easy-access cash ISAs have consistently outperformed or at least equalled the top-paying easy access normal savings. So unless the personal savings allowance skews the market, it's still worth using them.

  • Cash ISA fixes have much better terms

    To get a normal fixed-rate savings account you need to lock your money away with no access. Yet cash ISA rules stop providers doing this, so even if you get a fixed rate they have to allow you access to your cash, though they can levy interest penalties. So here you get the flexibility of access but the rate certainty of a fix.

  • Your tax situation may change

    Higher-rate taxpayers get a lower allowance than basic-rate payers and additional-rate taxpayers don't get one at all. If it's likely you could move up a tax bracket in future, having cash in an ISA now again protects your cash in future.

  • Spouses can inherit their deceased partner's ISA allowance

    This means the tax free status remains, yet personal savings allowances can't be passed on.

It is worth noting though that there isn't a 'personal investment allowance', so if you want to invest you should use your stocks & shares ISA allowance ahead of your cash allowance if that provides greater gain.

Bank account rates can smash cash ISA rates out the water

Cash ISAs broadly have similar rates to top normal savings, yet a few bank accounts pay far higher rates on savings as loss leaders to encourage you to switch. Though they tend to be on smaller amounts of cash, they can be worth filling before using up your ISA allowance.

  • For bigger savers, 1.5% interest + up to 3% cashback: The Santander 123* bank account is the only one which pays strong rates on a decent whack. You get 1.5% AER variable interest on up to £20,000 in it, 50% more than the current top-paying easy access ISA.

    It has a £5/month fee, but for most that's more than covered as it also pays up to 3% cashback on direct debits paid from the account – such as mobile phones, energy and council tax. This earns some over £10 a month.
  • Get up to 3% AER on £5,000. Another decent option is Bank of Scotland's Classic Account, which pays 3% on balances between £3,000 and £5,000. Plus, it's possible to open three of these accounts, thereby getting 3% on £15,000.
  • Get 5% AER fixed for a year on £2,500: Nationwide's FlexDirect pays a whopping 5% AER on £2,500, fixed for the first year of holding the account, though it falls to 1% AER variable from year two onwards.
  • Free £100 (£75 from 1 Mar) + £3 each month you're in credit. The Halifax Reward account pays this regardless of how much you've got. As this amount isn't related to the amount you have in it, it beats Bank of Scotland for most averaging under £1,800 in their account even before the £100.
  • Want to save monthly, not a lump sum? First Direct*, which has never failed to win our customer service polls, gives new customers £125 when they switch their account. HSBC's Advance* account gives £150 to switch and another £50 if you stay for a year. M&S Bank gives a £50 M&S gift card to switch plus £5/mth for two years. All also have linked 5% regular savings accounts where you can save aound £250-£300 a month.

If you are planning to open one of these, most require you to pass a credit check, make a minimum monthly deposit, and usually will require you to set up a couple of direct debits. Full pros and cons and how to open multiple accounts in the 5% savings loophole.

So if bank account rates are so much higher, surely they beat ISAs?

For many people yes, but not always. Here are the pros and cons:

  • Your bank rate may not last for ever. Bank accounts' interest rates are variable, so they can change either due to UK base rate moves or simply at the banks' whim. Easy-access cash ISA rates are of course variable too – but putting money in an ISA now means it's not just tax-free this year, it remains tax-free year after year.

    So even if your provider's rate drops, you can transfer to another provider to boost the rate and retain the boon of its tax-free status.

  • Risk & Reward DiceYour bank will credit check you, a cash ISA provider won't. To get a new bank account you need to pass a credit check, and this leaves an application footprint on your file. It's not a big issue, but you may want to avoid it just before something like a mortgage application. Plus you'll also need to meet its £500 minimum monthly deposit criteria to get the good rates.

    With a cash ISA there's no credit scoring and no income is needed to be paid in to it to earn the interest and keep the account.

Get Our Free Weekly Email!

For all the latest deals, guides and loopholes - join the 10m who get it. Don't miss out