Would you buy an elephant for a fiver?
The idea of getting less of anything for more money is the opposite of what we stand for here at MSE, and definitely seems counter-intuitive when it comes to grocery shopping.
So I, like lots of MoneySavers, always compare the price per unit, rather than total cost when buying groceries to ensure I get the best value for money.
Often 560g boxes of Alpen are on offer for £2 for example, but this still makes them more expensive than the 1.3kg bags at full price. However, while it’s a saving, it’s easy to forget that this theory only works if you want more.
I was reminded of this recently when talking to my boyfriend on the phone and he started to crunch Minstrels.
Knowing the sharing bags were on offer for £1 in several supermarkets, I said I hoped he was munching his way through one of those, but alas, he’d paid 59p for a bag a quarter of the size.
When I told him he should have bought a bigger bag because it would have been more cost-effective, he laughed and said "no it wouldn’t, because I didn’t want a bigger bag".
My Dad has a saying for situations like this – "elephants for a fiver" – meaning unless a deal is for something you really want, it’s not a deal worth having. How could I have forgotten this simple rule?
The dangers of bulk-buying
But that conversation with my boyfriend got me thinking about items on special offer I’ve bulk-bought in the past, and while I concluded those purchases weren’t a false economy like the Minstrels, as I did want and use them, I realised another threat to my purse is sometimes at play: frivolity.
I wouldn’t call myself a frivolous person, yet I’ve realised the more I have of something, the quicker I tend to use it, and therefore the sooner I have to buy it again (a mentality I’m sure supermarkets are well aware of when devising multi-buy offers).
And I doubt I’m the only one.
What are your thoughts? Let us know in the comments section below or in the forum discussion.
Have your say
This is an open discussion but the comments do not represent the views of MSE. We want everyone to enjoy using our site but spam, bullying and offensive comments will not be tolerated. Posts may be deleted and repeat offenders blocked at our discretion. Please contact fbteam@moneysavingexpert.com if you wish to report any comments.