How to beat normal savings by trading interest for air miles
Virgin Money has reissued its one-year fixed savings account, offering Flying Club air miles instead of cash interest. While it's not for everyone, work it right and you could be flying high on future trips.
The Virgin Atlantic One-Year Flying Club savings account doesn't pay interest in cash as with most savings accounts. Instead, savers get Virgin Atlantic air miles, which can be used for reward flights worldwide.
We first wrote about the account when it launched back in June 2018. Our analysis at the time showed cash interest was a better option for most. But with the top traditional one-year fixed savings accounts now paying less than inflation, meaning their value is dropping in real terms, this Virgin Money account can be worthwhile if you're planning to visit somewhere Virgin Atlantic flies to – especially if you like to fly in luxury.
And while we're aware many people are putting travel plans on hold in light of Covid-19 fears, this account's very much one for the future, as you only get the miles after a year of 'savings'.
How does the account work?
Like a traditional fixed-rate bond, you lock away your cash for a year in exchange for a guaranteed return at the end of the term. But instead of cash interest, you get 1,600 miles for every £1,000 saved.
To open an account you'll need a Virgin Atlantic Flying Club membership number, though if you aren't already a member you can join the club for free.
No withdrawals are allowed during the term. At the end of 12 months, any earned miles will be credited to your Flying Club account within five working days of the maturity date. Following this, the account will no longer earn you any miles and you'll be able to move your cash into another account.
Is it any good?
Virgin Money claims that the one-year interest rate is equivalent to 1.36% AER or a higher 2.4% AER if you compare it to buying Virgin Flying Club Miles direct from Virgin Atlantic. While this quoted 2.4% 'comparison rate' looks very enticing at first glance, buying Flying Club Miles in cash is an expensive way to obtain miles, so it's probably best to take it with a pinch of salt.
In terms of other fixed savings accounts available, the top standard one-year fix is currently from app-only Atom Bank, which pays 1.6% AER – seemingly dwarfing the Virgin account. Atom's account can be opened with £50, and cash interest is paid annually or monthly. If you don't fly, or won't be visiting anywhere Virgin Atlantic flies, then you'll likely be better off saving with Atom.
But as we show below, the Virgin account can win in some cases, particularly if you redeem the miles for trips in its upper class cabins. Of course, flying upper class is never MoneySaving, but if you're going to do it anyway, paying with miles can cut the cost dramatically.
It's important to note that the value of Virgin's miles could change without notice in the future, as could the taxes, fees and surcharges payable on reward flights. So before opting for this account, it's important to do your own research on top to make sure it's right for you.
The table below offers a snapshot of the reward flights you could get and the possible savings (or losses) compared to putting the same amount of money in the Atom account and then paying for the flight in cash.
How Virgin Atlantic 'savings' fare against normal savings
|Destination (1)||Cabin||Cost in cash (2)||Cost in miles
+ taxes (2)
|Savings needed to get miles||Potential cash interest (3)||Amount saved/lost booking with miles (4)
|New York City||Upper class||£2,664||95,000
|New York City||Economy||£351
In summary, while it's possible to make small savings by redeeming miles for economy flights on some routes, the Virgin Flying Club savings account works best if you redeem the miles you earn for flights in Virgin's upper class cabins, where you get the most bang for your (air mile) buck.
What else can I get with Flying Club miles?
It's also possible to redeem Virgin Atlantic air miles on flights with its partner airlines, which can offer decent value:
- Fly economy from New York City to Los Angeles for 25,000 miles + £9 in fees. Virgin partners with Delta Air Lines for domestic US flights. Depending on your itinerary, booking with miles through Virgin can work out cheaper than paying in cash. For example, we found a return flight for a week in September for 25,000 miles + £9 in fees, while the cheapest Delta flight for the same dates would cost £262 if you paid in cash – a £3 saving. (You'd need £15,625 in savings with Virgin to earn 25,000 miles.)
- Domestic flights in Japan for 15,000 miles. If you're planning a trip across Japan, domestic flights with All Nippon Airways can be booked through Virgin for 15,000 miles regardless of the distance. (You'd need £9,375 in savings with Virgin to earn this amount of miles.) While of course this isn't as environmentally friendly as taking the Shinkansen (sometimes called the 'bullet train'), it can be quicker. For example, flying from Tokyo Haneda to Sapporo takes around one and a half hours, compared to around seven hours on the train.
You can also redeem Virgin air miles for cabin upgrades or discounts on Virgin Atlantic flights and reward flights on other partner airlines (including Air France, Air New Zealand and KLM), as well as at some hotel chains (eg, Hilton and IHG). Of course, the value you get from each of these will vary, so check before you redeem.
What other ways are there to earn Virgin air miles?
If you don't want to lock away your cash for a year, one other option is a reward credit card:
- The fee-free Virgin Atlantic Reward credit card (eligibility calc / apply*) gives 5,000 bonus Virgin Flying Club miles if you make a purchase of any amount within 90 days. It also gives 0.75 miles for every £1 spent on the card. Repay IN FULL to avoid 22.9% rep APR (22.9% annual interest on purchases).
- The £160 a year Reward+ card (eligibility calc / apply*) offers a higher 15,000 bonus miles on your first purchase within 90 days, and gives double the amount of ongoing miles – 1.5 for every £1 spent. Rep APR is 63.9% (incl fee), so repay IN FULL (there's 22.9% annual interest on purchases).
For more on these cards and their rewards, plus information about other airline reward cards, see our Airline Credit Cards guide.