Cheap Car Insurance Compare 200+ quotes & cashback

Updated
Deals: Weekly
Surveys: Monthly

The Money Team

The Money Team consists of Dan, Alana, Wendy and Sally, and they have worked together to write and update this guide. Martin oversees the process with this guide.

The Consumer Team

The Consumer Team consists of Archna, Jenny, Rose and Becca, and they have worked together to write and update this guide.

New to the site? Quick message from Martin:

All the latest deals, guides and loopholes go in MoneySavingExpert's
free weekly email. Don't miss out - join the 6m who get it emailed!

FAQs | Unsubscribe 
Past Emails | Privacy



This powerhouse system severs car insurance costs - so powerfully the record result is 96p a year for fully comp. First, combine comparison site results to massively increase the number of quotes, then grab hidden cashback.

Step 1: Follow the DOs & DON'Ts

Insurance premiums (the payments you make to insurers) depend on three things:

Chosen insurer, plus level of cover, plus your risk level

By reducing insurers perception of your risk, you can reduce the price you'll pay.

Car insurance rates are set by actuaries, whose job is to calculate risk. Each insurer's price depends on two things; their underwriters' assessment of your particular risk focus, and then their own pricing model which dictates what customers they want to attract. See the following for ways to reduce your risk:

Watch the video guide
Courtesy of five tv. Originally from It Pays To Watch



(Jan 2009)

Step 2: Correctly combine comparison sites

Comparison sites zip your details to hosts of insurers' and brokers' websites, scraping their data off the screens to report back the cheapest. So be aware they often feed your personal details to insurers.

Yet these screenscrapers don't all compare the same sites, so the best strategy's to combine them. We've analysed the comparison sites, using a large range of monthly data, primarily focused on which ones produce the cheapest results for each category, but also factoring in user feedback. (see How the order is picked).

We also carried out our own research in obtaining quotations, the speed, how informative the process and end results are and what you need look out for...

Compare in the following order:

Cheapest quote 46% of time (in our sample)

Approx. time to get a quote 7 mins

GoComparetry it*

1. GoCompare ...Gets the cheapest quote 46% of the time (in our sample)

  • Pros: Clearly shows the total compulsory & voluntary excess. Good function to 'customise quote'. Quotations page includes ticks showing the cover/add-ons provided. Option to compare up to 4 policy covers.

  • Cons: Voluntary excess defaults to £250 & limited options to amend (down to £100 or up to £250). Windscreen excess not stated. Assumptions are pre-ticked & contacted within 5 mins when not 'opting-out' of being contacted.

  • Average quotes returned: 86
  • Add feedback: GoCompare

Top two of sample likely to give cheapest quote likely to give cheapest quote 70% of time.

Search Takes
8 mins

Confused.comtry it*

2. ...plus Confused.comIncreases chances of cheapest quote from sample to 70%

  • Pros: Good options to reduce the excess & clearly shows the total compulsory/voluntary excess. Simple filtering sytem. If you buy via Confused.com by 31 Mar 2012, you are able to claim 1,000 Nectar points.

  • Cons: Voluntary excess set at £250. Windscreen excess not stated & the option to edit quotations is not very clear or simple. The assumptions are pre-ticked. Was contacted when not 'opting-out' of being contacted.




stop!

Check the big 'uns they miss …..

AvivaAviva*: Currently has a special offer for new customers who buy online. Until the 30 May 2012 is giving 15 weeks of free car insurance. Insure a 2nd car, and you could save up to 33% through its multi-car discount.

Direct lineDirect Line*: As highlighted, Direct Line does not appear on comparison sites but is worth a look.

Top three of sample likely to give cheapest quote 85% of time

Another 6 mins to obtain a quotation

MoneySupermarket try it*

3. ... plus MoneySupermarketIncreases chances of cheapest quote from sample to 85%

  • Pros: Quickest in input time. The total compulsory & voluntary excess clearly shown. Good option to compare policy covers. Simple filtering system. Confirmation email of the quotation received.

  • Cons: Assumptions automatically completed - even the vehicle's value!. Windscreen excess not stated. Edit quotations function not clear. Was contacted within 60 seconds by telephone for not 'opting-out' of marketing calls, though I could not find the 'opt-out' option.

Top four of sample likely to give cheapest quote 94% of time.

Takes 6 mins to obtain a quotation

TescoCompare try it*

4. ... plus TescoCompareIncreases chances of cheapest quote from sample to 94%.

  • Pros: Good 'opt-out' options across the Tesco range. Clearly shows the cover provided and the additional premium to include add-ons such as breakdown, legal expenses or courtesy car. Earn ClubCard points.

  • Cons: Assumptions automatically completed, and the vehicle's value!. Windscreen excess not stated. No 'edit quotation' function - you need to use the 'back' button. No filtering option. More 'no quotes' than 'quotes'.

Total...
(close to) 100% chance of cheapest quote, based on insurers comparison sites cover.

5. Boost chances to nearly 100%Try to really nail down all the quotes

If you still haven't found a deal you're happy with or want to push the envelope there are some more options to try.

Plus try the following comparison sites if you have time - each takes around 5-10 minutes: Comparethemarket*, Beathatquote*, QuoteZone*, uSwitch*.

If you've used Beatthatquote before and you're awaiting your cash back, you can now submit a claim using the appropriate form.

Finally, if you still haven't found a deal you're happy with or want to push the envelope there are many more options to try. These other comparison sites between them will add around thirty providers (though there are more standalone insurers):

QuoteZone: Slower as nothing's pre filled in. Try it: QuoteZone*
CompareTheMarket: Be careful of the £500 default excess. Try it: CompareTM*

What they don't tell you: Some of the most competitive deals argent available on comparison sites

Comparison sites have attempted to tackle the market by offering quick cashback if you compare then get a policy through them. While it doesn't pay nearly as well as some hidden cashback deals (see step 4), it could still be enough to make a difference.

Money ExpertMoneyExpert:
This site pays £25 cashback, but currently its sister, SimplySwitch*, is bumping the offer to £40 if you go via its site and enter the code SIMPLYCAR. Important: How to get the cashback

MoneyExpert has set its default excess to £400 and includes some assumptions, so be careful to check the quotes are right for you.

Add feedback/read others:, MoneyExpert Car Ins

Always double check the policy terms...

Once you've found the cheapest quotes from the screenscrapers, make two important checks:

  • Double check the quotes

    Click through to the insurance provider's own website to double check the quotes, as to speed up searches some comparison sites make a few assumptions (see what to check).

  • Examine the policy's coverage

    Check whether its suitable. So if you want free car hire if your car is being fixed, is it included?

    While you're there, it's worth playing with the policy details to see if you can finesse the price down. Look at the excess, and whether adding drivers cuts the cost.

    This tool by Find* allows you to check the coverage of two different policies side by side.

What happens if my insurer goes bust?

Insurance providers regulated in the UK are covered by the same government-backed Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) as banks, meaning if they go into default, you're protected.

Comparison sites include many providers, the vast majority of which are regulated. A small number aren't, for example Markerstudy which is regulated in Gibraltar (meaning you'll need to claim from there if it's your insurer and it goes bust), so it's always worth checking yourself if you're concerned.

In the unlikely event a regulated insurer does goe bust, the FSCS will try to find another provider to take over or issue a substitute policy. However, if you've ongoing claims, or need to claim before a new insurer is found, the FSCS should ensure you're covered. For more see the Insurance section of the Savings Safety guide.

Step 3: Check Special Policies

Once you've tried the comparison sites, it's worth trying these extra ways to see if they undercut your best price.

Pay when you drive

A tracking device is fitted to your car to monitor when you drive - so the more you drive, the more you pay (though of course, it's also likely to depend on your personal risk profile).

Coverbox. A pay as you drive scheme from Coverbox* has per mile charges that vary according to the time of the day or night when you drive.

For low mileage drivers these can cut costs, especially if you don't drive at night (11pm - 5am) when the costs per mile jump.

Young, low use drivers or provisional licence holders

As a first port of call young drivers should always follow the same system, using the comparison services and trying to get cashback. However, if that hasn't cut costs there are further options which may help. See the full Young Driver Car Insurance guide for more detail.

Try a local broker

Some groups, eg, those in areas of high crime or with lots of penalty points, can find it incredibly difficult to find cheap insurance cover as they are considered too high a risk. Try speaking one-on-one to a local insurance broker about your individual circumstances to see if they can find you a decent policy (search on the British Insurance Brokers Association website).

Multi car discounts

Three cars If you've two or more vehicles between friends or family members in your household (Vans could be included in this but Bikes usually aren't), some providers offer discounts if you insure them all together. Comparison sites don't have the technology to do these searches, so you need to compare manually.

First, use comparisons for each car separately. The discounts are usually around 10%, so often it's likely just finding the cheapest standalone insurer will win anyway. So always do a comparison first then try the deals below to compare.

Get all cars on one policy. This is when all vehicles are covered on one policy (renewal dates will be aligned).

  • Admiral. Cover two or three cars and Admiral* will give up to 10% discount. Cover four or five and you could get up to 23% discount.
  • Aviva. Not included on comparisons anyway, Aviva* will give up to a 33% discount if you cover more than one vehicle.

Separate policies but still get the discount. Other insurers allow cars to have separate policies but give a discount as long as the vehicles are in the same household.

  • Privilege* gives up to 10% off
  • Direct Line* 10% off first year, 5% in the second. Plus, for a limited time, you will also receive 12 months for the price of 10.
  • Churchill* up to 15% off first year, 5% in the second.

Temporary car insurance

Its possible to get temporary insurance for 1 to 28 days, such as to to drive a friend's car, protecting their policy and no claims bonus. Budgets Temporary Insurance, Insure Daily, TempCover.com* and RAC are among some of the available policies.

Don't miss out on updates to this guide Get MoneySavingExpert's free, spam-free weekly email full of guides & loopholes

Step 4: Grab hidden cashback & discounts

By now you'll know the cheapest available provider, yet you may be able to cut the cost even further.

The top cashback deals

Once you know who your cheapest provider is, you need to check there aren't any hidden cashback deals, as these can be as high as £100. If your second or third cheapest quotes weren't too much more expensive see if cashback's available for them too, and find the overall winner.

The step-by-step list below takes you through a variety of options to improve your deal.

Check 1: Cashback websites

These sites carry paid links from some retailers and financial services providers; in other words if you click through them and get a product they get paid. They then give you some of this cash which means you get the same product, but a cut of its revenue.

Don't choose based only on cashback, see it as a bonus once you've picked the right cover...

Those new to cashback sites should ensure they read the Top Cashback Sites guide for pros and cons before using them. Otherwise use the Cashback Sites Maximiser tool to find the highest payer for each insurer.

Things you need to know before doing this...

  • Never count the cash as yours until it's in your bank account. This cashback is never 100% guaranteed, there can be issues with tracking and allocating the payment, plus many cashback sites are small companies with limited backing, and you've no protection if anything happens to them.
  • Withdraw the cashback as soon as you're allowed. Money held in your cashback site account has no protection at all if that company went bust, so always withdraw it as soon as you're eligible.
  • Clear your cookies. While it shouldn't be a problem, if you've used comparison sites beforehand, there is a minor risk that the cashback may not track due to cookies - so its good practice to clear those first (read About Cookies).

Check 2: Get cashback via comparison sites

If cashback sites don't list your insurer, try a comparison site that pays cashback if you compare then get a policy via their sites.

MoneyExpert pays £25 (although currently its sister, SimplySwitch*, is topping the offer up to £40 if you go via its site and enter the code SIMPLYCAR).

Again though, its more important to get the right policy than a bit of cashback, so ensure that first. However, you must make sure you tick all the right boxes to claim this cashback, and understand that the comparison sites pay this bonus directly - not the insurers - so you are reliant on their ability to pay. Please read the quick cashback section above for full pros and cons.

Check 3: Special deals

If you can't get cashback it's worth noting a few companies have special deals not always mentioned by comparison services. These currently include (listed alphabetically):

Aviva

If you opt to buy a motor policy via the AA*, you will automatically be given Free AA Breakdown cover for the first year if you are a new AA customer.

Aviva

Aviva* Currently has a special offer for new customers who buy online. Until the 30 May 2012 are giving 15 weeks of free car insurance. Insure a 2nd car, and you could save up to 33% through its multi-car discount.

Be Wiser: Insurance broker

Insurance broker Be Wiser* is giving free RAC membership for policies bought via its website.

Aviva

Buy Churchill* Motor Insurance by 31 Mar 2012, and you will receive 12 months cover for the price of 10 and quotations will be valid for up to 90 days. A minimum premium will apply.

Confused Docs

Until, 31 May 2012, buy a motor policy via Confused.com* and you'll get 1,000 Nectar points (worth £5). A claim form needs to be completed within 60 days of taking out the policy to validate your points. Other T&C's apply.

Aviva

Direct Line* does not appear on comparison sites. If you buy a policy by 29 Feb 2012, you will receive a 20% discount and be entitled to 0% APR if you pay monthly for the first year. A minimum premium will apply.

Natwest

If you are a NatWest* current account holder, you will receive a 15% discount for taking out a new car insurance policy. Also, if you are already a NatWest home insurance policy, you will get a further 10% off.

Natwest

Until 31 Mar 2012, buy a Post Office* motor policy and you will get free breakdown cover. If you are aged 50 or over, you will also get a 10% discount on your car insurance and free keycare cover. These offers only apply for the first year.

Sainsburys

Sainsbury's* Nectar cardholders who buy a comprehensive motor policy by the 8 Feb 2012 will get a 20% online discount. Also, until the 9 Apr 2012, you will receive free breakdown cover. This is in addition to receiving double Nectar points for a year on your Sainsbury's shopping and fuel.

Tesco

Buy your car insurance via Tesco and there's up to 10% off when buying online, and if you are a Clubcard holder, this increases to a 15% discount.

Haggle on your car insurance!

The car insurance market is very competitive and companies are desperate to retain business. Therefore once you've got your overall cheapest price get on the phone and try to haggle. There's often massive price flexibility, but be fully armed with the screenscrapers' cheapest quotes and any available cashback first.

The first port of call should be your existing insurer. If it can beat or even match the best quote it saves the hassle of switching policy. If that doesn't work and you're still in the mood, take it to a broker. For more haggling tips read the full Haggle On The High Street guide.

Step 5: Remember next year

alarm clock picture

Fortunately, providing you drive well and don't have any accidents, your insurance premium should get cheaper after the first year. However, don't automatically stick with the same provider - it may not still be cheapest.

Apply for cover from your existing insurer as a new customer and its likely you'll be given a cheaper price. This is because car insurers, like any company, will happily profit from apathy if they can.

Insurers must send out renewal notifications at least 28 days before renewal, though this doesn't leave much time, and you can end up rushing to try and find a cheaper price.

To avoid being forced to decide quickly, put a warning in your diary six weeks before your renewal date, so there's plenty of time to sort out a new provider. Alternatively use the free Tart Alert which sends a reminder text or email.

Warning! Women's car insurance to rise

An EU court ruling - that from Dec 2012 gender can't be a factored into insurance prices - means that as women under 40 pay much less than men under 40, they need to expect gradual rises until then. See the MSE news story Insurance costs to soar for full info.

Get paid to be a mystery shopper

You could also sign up to Consumer Intelligence, a consumer research company, which pays several hundred people a month near renewal up to £50 to carry out comparisons. Importantly, you don't need to buy insurance from any of the companies you've contacted. See the It's a Mystery forum thread for full details.

The current record result

This technique often produces huge savings. Those who normally just accept their insurers' renewal regularly see £100s shaved off the cost. And significant numbers of Money Savers report getting deals for under £100.

The Record... 96p for a years fully comprehensive cover

In October 2009, civil servant and grandmother Barbara Wakerell smashed the old £14 record for using this car insurance system (see MSE News: 96p car insurance).

  • Policy Price: For Barbara the cheapest was £120.96 from Swinton Insurance for a fully comprehensive policy, with protected no claims bonus, and including a courtesy car.

  • Insurer cashback: The company had its own £70 cashback promo on.

  • Cashback site: She then got a further £50 via using a cashback site.

All added together, that mean't the total cost of the insurance was just 96p. Her comment, "I'm always looking for a bargain so when I found my car insurance for £120.96 I thought I was doing well. But when I also got £120 cashback I realised I had done really, really well. Can anyone beat that?"

Have you used this guides techniques to save on car insurance? If so, pls feedback in the Car Ins Super Deals forum discussion.

Car insurance Q&A

Glossary

Join in the Forum Discussion:
Car Insurance

What the * means above

In the main body of the article two types of links are listed. The first, which all have a * within the main body of the articles, help MoneySavingExpert.com stay free to use, as they're 'affiliated links' which invisibly take you usually via affiliate linkage or commercial money sites, which then pay this site. It's worth noting this means the third party used may be named on any credit agreements.

The second type doesn't help and therefore doesn't have a *. You shouldn't notice any difference, the links don't impact the product at all and the editorial line (the things we write) is NEVER impacted by the revenue - we aim to look at all available products. If it isn't possible to get an affiliate link for the best product, it is still included in exactly the same way. For more details read how this site is financed.

Important FSA Note. Referring people to insurers or insurance intermediaries can in some circumstances require FSA authorisation. For this reason, Martin Lewis of Shepherd's Studios, Rockley Road, Shepherd's Bush, London W14 0DA is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority.

Duplicate links of the * links above for the sake of transparency, but this version doesn't help MoneySavingExpert.com: Admiral, Aviva, Be Wiser, Beatthatquote, Churchill, Compare the market, Confused.com, Coverbox, Direct Line, Find, GoCompare, MoneyExpert, Moneysupermarket, NatWest, Privilege, Quotezone, Sainsbury's, SimplySwitch, TempCover, TescoCompare, The AA, Uswitch


Cheap Travel Money

Find the best online rate for your holiday cash with MoneySavingExpert's TravelMoneyMax.