MoneySavingExpert.com homepage
Cutting your costs, fighting your corner
Founder, Martin Lewis · Editor-in-Chief, Marcus Herbert
Search bar closed.
polls-purple

Should we split the banks up?

23 January 2011

Poll started 24 January 2011: Should we split the banks up? Too big to fail, that's the cry. The independent commission on banking is debating whether we should split banks into their retail (the old fashioned credit cards, mortgages etc) and investment arms (the gambling bit, trading, international finance). The Pros:  It's the retail arm that people worry more about failing, and it's the investment side that's riskier. So the split would leave the bits we use less likely to fail. The Cons:  Many of the investment arms, which provide huge billions to the UK in tax receipts in good times, may leave and it'd be a real hit to the exchequer, meaning higher taxes or bigger cuts.

pollDefault.jpg

Poll started 24 January 2011:

Should we split the banks up?

Too big to fail, that's the cry. The independent commission on banking is debating whether we should split banks into their retail (the old fashioned credit cards, mortgages etc) and investment arms (the gambling bit, trading, international finance).

  • The Pros:  It's the retail arm that people worry more about failing, and it's the investment side that's riskier. So the split would leave the bits we use less likely to fail.

  • The Cons:  Many of the investment arms, which provide huge billions to the UK in tax receipts in good times, may leave and it'd be a real hit to the exchequer, meaning higher taxes or bigger cuts.

Results

A. Split the banks up 3,124 votes (65 %)
B. Keep it as is. 1,656 votes (35 %)

                   4,780 votes received.

We try to use technology to limit voting to one per person. Occasionally, this may erroneously block a few people's votes (eg, from shared offices). Apologies for that.

MSE Forum

Discuss this poll

Forum image
Tools and calculators

Clever ways to calculate your finances

Find your odds of getting top cards
Find your odds for getting a cheap loan
Compare broadband, phone & TV deals
Compares thousands of mortgages
Eight calcs to help you work out the cost
We ensure you’re on the cheapest tariff