MoneySavingExpert.com homepage
Cutting your costs, fighting your corner
Founder, Martin Lewis · Editor-in-Chief, Marcus Herbert
Search bar closed.
vote-grey

Is it time to extend the smoking ban?

2 October 2017

There are 1.9m fewer British smokers since the ban was introduced in England, Wales and Northern Ireland a decade ago (11yrs ago in Scotland). The ban makes it illegal to smoke in an enclosed public place and within the workplace, though it doesn't apply to e-cigarettes. Is the ban right and should it be extended more? Please vote for ONE option under the category that applies to you.

poll-smokingban-extension.png

There are 1.9m fewer British smokers since the ban was introduced in England, Wales and Northern Ireland a decade ago (11yrs ago in Scotland). The ban makes it illegal to smoke in an enclosed public place and within the workplace, though it doesn't apply to e-cigarettes.

Is the ban right and should it be extended more?

Please vote for ONE option under the category that applies to you.

Results

I’m under 30 and have NEVER smoked (1718 votes)
Make the sale of cigarettes/tobacco illegal 249 votes (14%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces 346 votes (20%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces (except designated smoking areas) 827 votes (48%)
Keep the ban as it is 271 votes (16%)
Get rid of the smoking ban 25 votes (1%)
I’m under 30 and a smoker (283 votes)
Make the sale of cigarettes/tobacco illegal 28 votes (10%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces 11 votes (4%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces (except designated smoking areas) 52 votes (18%)
Keep the ban as it is 157 votes (55%)
Get rid of the smoking ban 35 votes (12%)
I’m under 30 and an ex-smoker (418 votes)
Make the sale of cigarettes/tobacco illegal 47 votes (11%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces 39 votes (9%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces (except designated smoking areas) 148 votes (35%)
Keep the ban as it is 163 votes (39%)
Get rid of the smoking ban 21 votes (5%)
I’m 30-50 and have NEVER smoked (3952 votes)
Make the sale of cigarettes/tobacco illegal 551 votes (14%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces 1194 votes (30%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces (except designated smoking areas) 1699 votes (43%)
Keep the ban as it is 476 votes (12%)
Get rid of the smoking ban 32 votes (1%)
I'm 30-50 and a smoker (891 votes)
Make the sale of cigarettes/tobacco illegal 111 votes (12%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces 26 votes (3%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces (except designated smoking areas) 114 votes (13%)
Keep the ban as it is 507 votes (57%)
Get rid of the smoking ban 133 votes (15%)
I’m 30-50 and an ex-smoker (2245 votes)
Make the sale of cigarettes/tobacco illegal 309 votes (14%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces 345 votes (15%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces (except designated smoking areas) 861 votes (38%)
Keep the ban as it is 644 votes (29%)
Get rid of the smoking ban 86 votes (4%)
I’m over 50 and have NEVER smoked (3272 votes)
Make the sale of cigarettes/tobacco illegal 311 votes (10%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces 1309 votes (40%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces (except designated smoking areas) 1269 votes (39%)
Keep the ban as it is 349 votes (11%)
Get rid of the smoking ban 34 votes (1%)
I’m over 50 and a smoker (783 votes)
Make the sale of cigarettes/tobacco illegal 30 votes (4%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces 33 votes (4%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces (except designated smoking areas) 64 votes (8%)
Keep the ban as it is 444 votes (57%)
Get rid of the smoking ban 212 votes (27%)
I’m over 50 and an ex-smoker (2648 votes)
Make the sale of cigarettes/tobacco illegal 205 votes (8%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces 724 votes (27%)
Extend the ban to all outdoor public spaces (except designated smoking areas) 946 votes (36%)
Keep the ban as it is 653 votes (25%)
Get rid of the smoking ban 120 votes (5%)

                   16,210 votes received.

We try to use technology to limit voting to one per person. Occasionally, this may erroneously block a few people's votes (eg, from shared offices). Apologies for that.

MSE Forum

Discuss this poll

Forum image
Tools and calculators

Clever ways to calculate your finances

Find your odds of getting top cards
Find your odds for getting a cheap loan
Compare broadband, phone & TV deals
Compares thousands of mortgages
Eight calcs to help you work out the cost
We ensure you’re on the cheapest tariff