Should women and men pay the same for insurance?

Should women and men pay the same for insurance?

Poll started 28 Feb 2011:

Should women and men pay the same for insurance?

Today the European Court ruled that pricing insurance based on gender is unfair discrimination, which could throw insurance pricing into chaos.

While sometimes, such as with car insurance, young men pay more due to average behaviour so you could argue "would we allow the same based on race?", at other times, such as term life insurance women pay less as they live longer, so there it's not bias it's biology.

Please answer the following question:

Is it ok to charge different genders different amounts?

Results

I'm a man (4710 votes)
Yes: Insurers should be allowed to price on risk 2972 votes (63%)
No: It’s unfair discrimination; the price should be the same for both 1481 votes (31%)
Only on medical grounds: Differences due to behaviour should be banned 257 votes (5%)
I'm a woman (4668 votes)
Yes: Insurers should be allowed to price on risk 3989 votes (85%)
No: It’s unfair discrimination; the price should be the same for both 526 votes (11%)
Only on medical grounds: Differences due to behaviour should be banned 153 votes (3%)

                   9,378 votes received.

We try to use technology to limit voting to one per person. Occasionally, this may erroneously block a few people's votes (eg, from shared offices). Apologies for that.