MoneySavingExpert.com homepage
Cutting your costs, fighting your corner
Founder, Martin Lewis · Editor-in-Chief, Marcus Herbert
Search bar closed.
vote-grey

Train operators: who are the best and worst?

21 July 2014

We can tell you how to save the most from Cheap Train Tickets, but to find out if they’re any good, we need your help. Taking into account your whole experience – price, speed, reliability, comfort and service – please rate the operators you’ve used regularly over the past YEAR.

pollDefault.jpg

We can tell you how to save the most from Cheap Train Tickets, but to find out if they’re any good, we need your help.

Taking into account your whole experience – price, speed, reliability, comfort and service – please rate the operators you’ve used regularly over the past YEAR.

Results

Abellio Greater Anglia (725 votes)
Great 53 votes (7%)
OK 143 votes (20%)
Poor 529 votes (73%)
Arriva Trains Wales (333 votes)
Great 63 votes (19%)
OK 151 votes (45%)
Poor 119 votes (36%)
c2c (262 votes)
Great 158 votes (60%)
OK 78 votes (30%)
Poor 26 votes (10%)
Chiltern Railways (329 votes)
Great 211 votes (64%)
OK 89 votes (27%)
Poor 29 votes (9%)
CrossCountry (601 votes)
Great 132 votes (22%)
OK 295 votes (49%)
Poor 174 votes (29%)
East Coast (807 votes)
Great 531 votes (66%)
OK 209 votes (26%)
Poor 67 votes (8%)
East Midlands Trains (433 votes)
Great 147 votes (34%)
OK 208 votes (48%)
Poor 78 votes (18%)
First Capital Connect (522 votes)
Great 54 votes (10%)
OK 227 votes (43%)
Poor 241 votes (46%)
First Great Western (725 votes)
Great 198 votes (27%)
OK 275 votes (38%)
Poor 252 votes (35%)
First Hull Trains (140 votes)
Great 73 votes (52%)
OK 38 votes (27%)
Poor 29 votes (21%)
First TransPennine Express (496 votes)
Great 155 votes (31%)
OK 218 votes (44%)
Poor 123 votes (25%)
Grand Central (167 votes)
Great 83 votes (50%)
OK 56 votes (34%)
Poor 28 votes (17%)
Heathrow Connect (106 votes)
Great 37 votes (35%)
OK 49 votes (46%)
Poor 20 votes (19%)
Heathrow Express (190 votes)
Great 95 votes (50%)
OK 61 votes (32%)
Poor 34 votes (18%)
London Midland (449 votes)
Great 94 votes (21%)
OK 211 votes (47%)
Poor 144 votes (32%)
London Overground (469 votes)
Great 226 votes (48%)
OK 206 votes (44%)
Poor 37 votes (8%)
Merseyrail (214 votes)
Great 112 votes (52%)
OK 66 votes (31%)
Poor 36 votes (17%)
NI Railways (75 votes)
Great 22 votes (29%)
OK 28 votes (37%)
Poor 25 votes (33%)
Northern Rail (515 votes)
Great 62 votes (12%)
OK 213 votes (41%)
Poor 240 votes (47%)
ScotRail (353 votes)
Great 146 votes (41%)
OK 141 votes (40%)
Poor 66 votes (19%)
South West Trains (598 votes)
Great 163 votes (27%)
OK 249 votes (42%)
Poor 186 votes (31%)
Southern (475 votes)
Great 126 votes (27%)
OK 221 votes (47%)
Poor 128 votes (27%)
Southeastern (399 votes)
Great 72 votes (18%)
OK 151 votes (38%)
Poor 176 votes (44%)
Virgin Trains (1252 votes)
Great 760 votes (61%)
OK 375 votes (30%)
Poor 117 votes (9%)

           3,663 people have voted.

We try to use technology to limit voting to one per person. Occasionally, this may erroneously block a few people's votes (eg, from shared offices). Apologies for that.

MSE Forum

Discuss this poll

Forum image
Tools and calculators

Clever ways to calculate your finances

Find your odds of getting top cards
Find your odds for getting a cheap loan
Compare broadband, phone & TV deals
Compares thousands of mortgages
Eight calcs to help you work out the cost
We ensure you’re on the cheapest tariff