MSE News

Switch now: Martin's car and home insurance warning ahead of groundreaking rule changes

Martin Lewis | Money Saving Expert

Updated 16 November 2021 | Created 19 October 2021

On 1 January 2022, regulator the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) brings in new insurance rules. They primarily apply to vehicle insurance (car, motorbike, van) and home insurance (buildings & contents), but it's a monumental shake-up - the biggest I remember.

Update, 16 November 2021: This article was originally written by MoneySavingExpert.com founder Martin Lewis for the site's weekly email on 13 October 2021. It has today (16 November 2021) been updated by the MSE Team.

The aim is to end price walking, where those who loyally renew each year are penalised by seeing their prices put up - while new customers get the best deals. It may mean cheap switchers' deals end soon, so check now if you can lock in cheaply, even if not at renewal. There's full car insurance cost-cutting and home insurance cost-cutting help on the site, but here's what you need to know and do about the new rules.

1. From 1 Jan, car and home insurers must charge new and existing customers the same

I can hear the cheers. The loyalty premium has long been a bone of contention. It's great news for those who don't switch, or do but don't want the hassle. The rules say insurers must prove, on aggregate, that they charge new and existing customers the same, including any vouchers or cashback.

It's 'channel specific' too. For example, an insurer must give all customers renewing who first came via MoneySupermarket the same prices as new customers via the same method - but these can differ from prices via Gocompare, for example.

2. My guess is firms won't just cut renewals to match newbies' prices. They'll drop 'em somewhat, and increase new-customer rates - meeting towards the middle

That's why we may see an end to many cheap switchers' deals. I need to be plain here - I don't know that this will happen. My guess is based on similar past changes. The easiest example is from 2012, when insurers were barred from price discrimination based on gender.

Young male drivers had paid far more than female drivers. After we tried to factor out other price moves, it looks like young women saw prices rise, while young men saw them drop by even more.

Don't think savings got by switching will end totally though. Different insurers will still have different prices - and new entrants will try to disrupt the market - but savings will likely be smaller.

3. Rates may change before January, so checking now, while they're still cheap, is safest - you can switch even if not at renewal

While the new regime officially starts in January, as it's a big job, insurers will likely start to shift pricing algorithms sooner, so the clock is ticking and the cheapest prices may start to disappear within weeks or months.

The tips below will show you how to find cheap car insurance and cheap home insurance. Take a look even if renewal is six months away, to see if you can save significantly.

If you can, you'll need to cancel your existing policy, and provided you've not claimed or reported an incident this insurance year.

- You should get a pro-rata refund for the rest of the year minus a £30 to £50ish one-off admin fee. Factor that in to any savings.

- You might not earn this year's no-claims bonus though.

As Holly emailed us: "I'm so glad to get your emails. I wouldn't have thought to cancel my car insurance mid-year and start a new one which is £300/yr less." More help on how to save if not at renewal.

Even if you can't save now, but can match your current price, it may be worth doing in case prices rise. This is far shakier territory though, as it involves some crystal-ball gazing. So I'll leave that up to you.

4. Use more than one comparison to find your cheapest

Comparison sites are actually technically insurance marketplaces, as insurers are allowed to, and sometimes do, offer cheaper prices on individual sites than they charge direct.

Therefore it's not just that different sites cover different firms, but that different sites can have different prices for the same insurer. So for the widest comparison use at least two, and more if you've time.

Below is our current order to try (see how we pick the order). Though checking as many as you've time for is the key rule, rather than the order, so if any perks appeal, you can select your order based on that.

Car Insurance Comparison Order

Confused.com* car insurance

Official perk info: ONE of a... £20 Halfords voucher | £20 Domino's voucher | 12 IMO 'triple foam' car washes | £20 Lidl coupon.
MSE perk analysis: The highest value is the car washes, if you'd use them all, as they can cost £5 each elsewhere, so it's worth £60.

Compare The Market* car insurance

Official perk info: Meerkat Movies and Meals - a year's 2for1 on cinema tickets and meals on selected days of the week.

MSE perk analysis: For those who'd use it, going to the flicks and restaurants, this perk can be worth £100s. However, instead you could grab other perks, as you can use our trick to get Meerkat Movies and Meals for £1 for a year anyway.

MoneySupermarket* car insurance

Official perk info: Combination of up to £150 of car repair and servicing vouchers, eg, up to £30 off MOTs, £5 off wheel alignment work.
MSE perk analysis: Likely better for older cars that need more work. We analysed the value of these vouchers compared to the cheapest similar garages and found they could be worth up to £70 in a year.

Gocompare* car insurance

Official perk info: £250 'free' excess cover.
MSE perk analysis: Gives good peace of mind, but few will use the free excess in any given year. We value it at roughly £35 as that's a typical cost for an excess policy to cover a similar amount.

Comparison sites are best for those with straightforward circumstances. If your situation isn't mainstream, see help to get cover.

The order for home insurance...

The principle is the same, but not all have perks. Our order here is Compare The Market* (same perk) | Confused.com* (same perk) | MoneySupermarket* (no perk) | Gocompare* (no perk). And again if comparison sites don't work for you, see help to get cover.

5. Check for deals comparison sites miss

The big firm that's missing for car and home insurance is Direct Line* as it won't go on comparison sites (Aviva used to take this stance too, but now it's on them). It is worth checking as in some circumstances it is a winner.

There are also promotional deals that may not be on comparisons. The team have put together a list of car insurance promos - incl a £60 Amazon voucher, and home insurance promos - incl a £55 Amazon voucher.

6. Near renewal? Get quotes 23 days beforehand - leave it later and you can see prices double

The graph shows how car insurance quotes drop in price from 30 days before renewal to reach their cheapest point at 23 days ahead, before rising again the closer you get to renewal date.

The graph links to a full write-up on this MoneySaving method in the MSE Cheap Car Insurance guide. While today I'm pushing you to check if you can save regardless of timing, for those with renewals soon, timing can really help.

We analysed over 70 million quotes, and found the optimum time to get new car insurance quotes is 23 days ahead of renewal (21 days for home), but anytime around three weeks is good. Leave it later and car insurance prices can almost double because insurers' algorithms show those who get new quotes earlier are a lower risk (the rise is far less steep with home insurance).

We get huge numbers of successes on this. Ian emailed: "Brilliant advice - best price, about 21 days before expiry date, was £340. But day before expiry: £637."

Amanda emailed too: "I read your tip... and got a quote for £600 less than the renewal quote. Saved £960 total because I could now afford to pay in one go rather than monthly instalments. Thank you."

7. More than one car in the home? Multicar policies could save or cost you £100s

Multicar insurance policies aren'tincluded on comparison sites, so to find out if you'll save requires digital elbow grease.

My rule of thumb is first try the opposite to what you have, as insurance has always been about sucking in newbies with special deals. So if you've multicar, try standalone policies. Got standalone? Then try multicar.

The three pure multicar discount policies are from Admiral MultiCar*, Aviva* and LV*. All let you set up a policy at your 1st car's renewal, leaving the other car(s) on its existing insurer until their renewal. See multicar split-year renewals.

There are also multi-policy discounts, reducing the cost if you've two cars, or get car and home insurance together. These include More Than (15% off), Axa* (up to 15%), Esure* (10%), Privilege (varies) and Sheilas' Wheels* (10%). Plus, Direct Line* and Churchill also offer discounts for multiple cars.

Multicar worked for Kam, who told us on Facebook: "I saved £500 by sticking both my and my wife's car on a multicar policy."

But Nigel tweeted that splitting was better: "@MartinSLewis I was with multicar until at renewal they wanted over £1,300 for 3 cars. Got 3 individual policies for under £600."

8. Cashback sites can pay up to £70 if you get a policy via them, boosting your saving

If you're a cashback site user, you'll know that if you get your car and home insurance via it, and it's paid a lead fee for sending you to the insurer, then it shares it with you as cashback.

Yet do check your quote isn't more than via a comparison site. Plus think of the cashback as a bonus rather than 100% certain, as sometimes it doesn't track or isn't paid out - focus on the right product. Full info in car insurance & cashback, but there are two routes to try:

Route 1: Use cashback site comparisons. A rebranded version of Confused's comparison is used by cashback sites Topcashback* (get £42 for car, £35 home) and Quidco* (£40 car, £33 home) - though you don't get the normal Confused perks.

What I can't say is whether you'll get exactly the same price as going to Confused direct. This week, we got a small sample, 17 people from MSE Towers, to check. Nine got the same price from both cashback site comparisons as Confused, three got it cheaper, five more costly - but that could be due to dynamic pricing.

Route 2: Find your cheapest policy, then try for cashback. This may be more lucrative. Once you know your cheapest insurer after using a comparison site, check what cashback you'd get going to it direct via Quidco* or Topcashback*. You could get up to £70 for car insurance and £50 for home.

Yet be extra careful not to let the cashback tail wag the dog. Choose the right insurer first, then look for cashback. Don't choose the biggest cashback to make your choice of insurer.

9. Counter-logical CAR INSURANCE tricks

Insurance pricing is about risk, and that can have some strange consequences. For example, comprehensive cover may undercut third party, as while it covers more, the mere fact you selected it can change insurers' views of your risk profile to outweigh that.

Similar is true of tweaking your job description and, crucially, adding a responsible 2nd driver can bring down your risk average, especially for younger drivers, and mean you pay less.

10. Ensure you're insuring your HOME & contents correctly

Buildings insurance is normally only for freehold property owners - leaseholders and renters will usually be covered by that (though some leaseholders' circumstances may be different - so check). Do be careful not to overinsure buildings cover - cover the cost to rebuild it if knocked down, not to buy it. Use a rebuild cost calculator.

Everyone should consider contents insurance. An easy way to think of the difference is if you could upend your home, whatever falls (plus integrated items such as white goods) is its contents. Do beware underinsurance contents though, as you may not get a full payout.

11. Don't want to move... haggle

If you're happy where you are, ask your insurer to match the cheapest quote / best deal - it may even be from your same existing insurer, as the new rules haven't come in yet. Full help in Car & home insurance haggling (pls remember it's about charm and politeness, not aggression).

As Paul emailed: "Did the usual searches and then contacted my insurer. Got the price down from £2,500 to just over £1,900. Pays to haggle."

12. Ensure the policy is right for you and know your rights if you're unfairly treated/your claim is rejected

Before you sign up to a policy, spend time going through what it covers and the details to make sure you're happy with it, and check it is regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

If you believe your insurer has treated you unfairly, or rejected a claim it shouldn't, remember you have a right to take it to the independent, free Financial Ombudsman Service for it to adjudicate.

What the * means above
If a link has an * by it, that means it is an affiliated link and therefore it helps MoneySavingExpert stay free to use, as it is tracked to us. If you go through it, it can sometimes result in a payment or benefit to the site. It's worth noting this means the third party used may be named on any credit agreements.

You shouldn’t notice any difference and the link will never negatively impact the product. Plus the editorial line (the things we write) is NEVER impacted by these links. We aim to look at all available products. If it isn't possible to get an affiliate link for the top deal, it is still included in exactly the same way, just with a non-paying link. For more details, read How this site is financed.

Duplicate links of the * links above for the sake of transparency, but this version doesn't help MoneySavingExpert.com:

Admiral Multicar, Aviva, Axa, Compare The Market, Confused.com, Direct Line, Esure, Gocompare, LV, MoneySupermarket, Quidco, Sheilas' Wheels, Topcashback

MoneySupermarket.com Financial Group Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN: 303190). The registered office address of both MoneySupermarket.com Group PLC and MoneySupermarket.com Financial Group Limited (registered in England No. 3157344) is MoneySupermarket House, St. David's Park, Ewloe, Chester, CH5 3UZ. MoneySavingExpert.com Limited is an appointed representative of MoneySupermarket.com Financial Group Limited.

MSE weekly email

FREE weekly MoneySaving email

For all the latest deals, guides and loopholes simply sign up today – it's spam-free!

Show less

MSE Forum

Join the MSE Forum discussion

Switch Now: Martin's Car and Home Insurance Warning

MSE email

19 September 2023

FREE weekly MoneySaving email

Show less

For all the latest deals, guides and loopholes simply sign up today – it's spam-free!

FAQs Privacy Past Emails Unsubscribe

'Unfair' standing charges need to go: MPs back Martin's and MSE's calls for energy bill overhaul

23 September 2023

Energy standing charges unfairly penalise households on lower incomes and those looking to cut their usage, a cross-party group of MPs have said in a new report published today.
Martin Lewis: Urgent warning for savers as base rate held at 5.25%

22 September 2023

You should open a fixed savings rate NOW in case rates are cut, MoneySavingExpert.com founder Martin Lewis has warned.
Martin Lewis: Are you an E.on customer? Here's an easy way to cut what you pay for energy

21 September 2023

E.on Next's 'Pledge' tariff could be an easy way to cut your bills over the next year, according to MoneySavingExpert.com founder Martin Lewis.
NatWest and RBS to close at least 134 branches in 2023/24 – here's the full list, plus alternatives

21 September 2023

The NatWest Group will shut at least 143 of its bank branches throughout 2023 and 2024 following its latest announcement.
Bank of Scotland, Halifax and Lloyds to close 35 more branches in 2023/24 – here's the full list, plus alternatives

21 September 2023

Bank of Scotland, Halifax and Lloyds, which are all part of the Lloyds Banking Group, have announced they'll close at least 35 more branches between them over the next 12 months.